Welcome to LinuxMedNews
 up a level
 post article
 search
 admin
 Contact
 main


  List of Active FOSS EMR/EHR's
Medical Open Source Development Posted by Ignacio Valdes, MD, MS on Monday June 14, 2004 @ 01:50 AM
from the Medical-Open-Source-Development dept.
Here's about as good a summary as you can get of currently active Free and Open Source Software EHR/EMR projects courtesy of Dan Johnson, MD. Dr. Johnson is the author of the earliest known writings on Free and Open Source Software in medicine. He continues his activity in this area.

Digg this article

June 11, 2004,

Dear Dr. Rollow, Mr. Weir, and Mr Moy:

Thank you for speaking to me this week about DOQ-IT and open source
software.

I promised that by today I would have prepared a summary of open source
EHR projects that I'm aware of. There is some very exciting work going
on. I will give you, below, a precis of each project and links. I will
cc the folks that offered me their information so that (a) you'll have
contact information and (b) they can correct any misrepresentations that
I inadvertently create.

I will also post this note to the open source healthcare discussion
list, so the folks there can correct my errors. You can tune into that
discussion by sending an e-mail to
openhealth-list-request@minoru-development.com with "subscribe" as the
subject. An archive of past messages is available at
www.mail-archive.com .

In addition, here's a link to a comprehensive, well-documented essay on
open source software and its market:
http://www.dwheeler.com/oss_fs_why.html It is very long; its author has
kept it up do date for at least 4 years, and I've found it a useful
encyclopedia of open source references.

An extensive list of open source health care software resources is
maintained at
http://www.minoru-development.com/en/healthlinks.html#projects (but is
not current beyond 2002). Other lists of open source EHR projects are
at http://www.debian.org/devel/debian-med/practice and
http://mtdata.com/drred/public_html/webpage.html as well as
http://www.linuxmednews.com/, the open-source healthcare new site, run
by the psychiatrist Iganacio Valdes, MD, which maintains an excellent
list at
http://www.linuxmednews.com/linuxmednews/LMNProjects/Projects/folder_contents


Now follows the list of open-source EHR vendors.

1: Project: tkfp http://tkfp.sourceforge.net/
Lead: Alexander Caldwell M.D. alcald2000@yahoo.com
Developers: 10
Use in practices: 2
Tech support: informal, active
Supports billing: yes
Lab interface: yes

Special feature: designed to incorporate practice guidelines:
Has integration with "MedMapper" -- http://medmapper.sourceforge.net/
-- an interactive electronic algorithm-like decision support system that
is the brainchild of David Pepper M.D. drpepper@ucsfresno.edu This
allows tight integration of decision support for the EMR with
documentation in the patient record. This system prompts physicians in
real time, creating dynamically editable templates for our note writing
that allow best practice and practice guidelines to be incorporated
directly into the note templates.

A *very* interesting concept; *not* formally commercial.


2: Project: OpenEMed http://65.125.35.7/ http://openemed.org/
Lead: David Forslund forslund@mail.com
Developers: several
Use in practices: being installed as part of the SHARE project in
Mendocino County, CA.
Tech support: informal, active
Supports billing: no
Lab import: yes

Special features: OpenEMed is a set of distributed healthcare
information service components built around the OMG distributed object
specifications and the HL7 (and other) data standards and is written in
Java for platform portability.
In addition, it includes a complete JSP client implementation of a
infectious disease monitoring system (B-SAFER) for use in an Urgent Care
setting. This includes filters for a variety of data feeds including
HL7, CSV, SQL, flat files, and XML. This powerful and flexible tool is
being used to acquire a variety of data from multiple hospital systems.
Also included is a example of a simple immunization registry pilot. The
power of using these components in a variety of settings can ultimately
lead to a fully distributed medical record accessible by a patient. This
could be ideal in a regional healthcare management scenario.
David Forslund has done some simply amazing work interconnecting
regional hospitals with disparate information systems in the Southwest,
and this project is an outgrowth of his work.

3: Projects: OSCAR http://67.69.12.117/ and EGADSS
http://sourceforge.net/projects/egadss/ and
http://www.netlab.uvic.ca:8008/sites/public/default.aspx plus
http://www.vch.ca/health_services/PHCN/UBC-VCH-BC-CDSS%20Services%20April%202004.pdf
and http://www.cms.hhs.gov/quality/ClinicalMeasures.pdf
Leads: David Chan, MD (OSCAR),
(contact Joseph Dal Molin, dalmolin@e-cology.ca
Morgan Price, MD (EGADSS) priceless@familymed.ca
Developers: 5, full time, employed
Use in practices: 4 or more in Canada (fully portable to the US)
Tech support: available commercially in Canada
Supports billing: partial, in Canada
Lab import: yes

Special features: OSCAR is a full-fledged office EHR developed by Dr.
David Chan of the McMasters University Family Practice program in
Hamilton, Ontario. This is the most sophisticated and complete open
source EHR. Dr. Chan has earned significant grant support for
development; the developers are eager to have US practices adopt and
extend OSCAR.
EGADSS is under initial development; it is designed to be a stand alone
reminder system that can interface with an EMR. EGADSS stands for
Evidence-based Guideline And Decision Support System.

4: Project: OpenEMR http://www.openemr.net/
Lead: Walt Pennington wpennington@pennfirm.com
Developers: 6
Use in practice: 175 clinics using or evaluating OpenEMR;
International use: Uganda pilot beginning
Tech support: available commercially from the Pennington Firm
Supports billing: yes
Supports lab import: in development

Special features: a functioning, commercially thriving, commercial
product based on the open source development model.
Pennington Firm http://www.PennFirm.com
402 West Broadway
4th Floor
San Diego, CA 92101-3554
619-696-5050 or 888-480-5050

Updated 10/09/2004 by IV:
5: Project: VistA
Lead: US Veterans Administration, OpenVistA
see http://www.worldvista.org/
https://sourceforge.net/projects/worldvista/
http://www.pacifichui.org/OpenVista/

Medsphere: http://www.medsphere.com/home/
http://sourceforge.net/projects/openvista Contact: Summer Bond
summer.bond@medsphere.com
Medsphere
65 Enterprise
Aliso Viejo, CA 92656
310-271-1232
Developers: several
Use in practice: hospital-based system
Developers: 5 in house
Sites: 7 hospitals
Tech support: full, commercial
Supports billing: yes
Supports lab: yes, and everything else

Special features: This is an example of VistA being ported to the
private sector. VistA is capable, I understand, of being a physician
office EHR, but I am not aware of commercial availability for this. I
believe that it is being used in the office setting in American Samoa.


6: Project: TORCH http://www.openparadigms.com/
Lead: Tim Cook Tim@openparadigms.com
Developers: 100+
Sites: Not tallied (I believe that Tim has a commercial product, based
on TORCH, in several practices that he supports commercially.)
Tech support: informal
Supports billing: yes, using FreeB (http://freeb.org/)
Supports lab interfaces: yes
Able to support QI guidelines: yes

Special features: TORCH is unique in that it is an actively-developed
code base that is available to developers. The TORCH2 project is an
object oriented and completely open source EHR
composed of components for; billing, practice management, accounting,
clinical coding, customizable workflow, graphing package, remote and
local scheduling using standard iCal documents, granular security model,
audit trail of every action, template and free text input is user
selectable, voice recognition (with additional software), hand writing
recognition (with additional hardware and software) and has interfaces
for PCs, PDAs and iPhones.

7: Project: CHLCare
Lead: Thomas Lewis MD
Contact: Marilyn Wetterhahn (?sp), Special Projects
Primary Care Coalition of Montgomery County
8757 Georgia Avenue, Silver Spring, MD 20910
(301) 628-3405
Details: none available see
http://www.egovos.org/Conferences/PastConf/March03/Agenda/TLewis/
http://www.coolheads.com/egov/combined/topicmap/s51/abstract.html

Special features: This is an Open Source, enrollment based, encounter
based, thin, broad, web based, extensible electronic medical record for
primary care support. I have heard a presentation on this system, but
can locate no information.

8: Project: FreeMED http://www.freemed.org/
Lead: Jeff Buchbinder
Developers: several
Sites: at least one. FreeMED was developed., I believe, circa 1997,
for the practice of Jeff's father, making it truly the first open source
EHR.
Tech support: http://www.freemed.org/mailman/listinfo/support
Supports billing: yes, through FreeB http://freeb.org/
Supports lab: not known

Special features: I'm sorry; I'm ignorant.

There are other open source health care projects as well, I'm confident
that I've missed one or more that are mature and deployed. but this is
what I'm able to provide over lunch and after patient care is finished.

As a Wisconsin PRO (MetaStar) trustee, I'm excited about the potential
that DOQ-IT has for beginning to bring coherence to the healthcare
office EHR arena.

Sincerely,

Dan Johnson md
715-235-9671





<  |  >

 

  Related Links
  • Articles on Medical Open Source Development
  • Also by Ignacio Valdes, MD, MS
  • Contact author
  • The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them.
    ( Reply )

    Re: List of Active FOSS EMR/EHR's
    by Andreas Tille on Monday June 14, 2004 @ 06:12 AM
    From the links you provided in the beginning you
    can find some more projects: GnuMed, OIO, Care2x,
    Circare, ResMedicinae, SQL Clinic and probably
    more.

    I have not done a deeper investigation in all
    projects you mentioned above. I think TORCH
    is well described, FreeMed deserves a more
    detailed description. The third project I had
    a look at in the past is TkFP. I have to add
    that I'm absolutely not convinced from the code
    quality of tkfp. I'm sorry I regard it as
    technical not acceptable to be used in a medical
    practice and I outlined this to some extend at

    http://people.debian.org/~tille/talks/paper/debian-med-4.html#ss4.4

    I do not know the other projects.

    Kind regards

    Andreas.
    [ Reply to this ]
    • Re: List of Active FOSS EMR/EHR's
      by Alex Caldwell M.D. on Tuesday June 15, 2004 @ 05:39 AM
      Regarding Tkfp, I would have to retort that it is proabably only natural that it's code base would reflect the learning curve of a practicing physician who is not a professional programmer, just just struggling to implement things he needs in a small daily office practice. I would like to have some of these things available to me before I retire. If I had to wait for the software engineering professionals to come up with an open source package for generating HCFA forms, I will probably be long since dead before it ever comes to fruition.

      I myself would not trust the Tkfp code to control a medical device that delivers radiation to human beings or one that does stereotactic surgery, but if you practice in the U.S. and need to generate HCFA 1500 forms so you can get paid, need to remember what medicines you have a patient on, and generate office notes, you might find Tkfp interesting.

      On the other hand, if you need a cuddly desktop Teddy Bear that sits on your X desktop that is very well engineered and meets all software engineering standards neccessary to be included in the Debian distrubution, you can get "XTeddy" maintained by Dr. Tilles at http://www.physik.uni-halle.de/~e2od5/debian/xteddy.html


      [ Reply to this ]
      • Re: List of Active FOSS EMR/EHR's
        by Andreas Tille on Tuesday June 15, 2004 @ 05:53 AM
        The reason for my posting was a slight hint where this program package might be enhanced. I found out the things I reported when I evaluated your package for integrating into the Debian GNU/Linux distribution. This intention is normally welcome by software developers because it often leads to enhancements.

        I just ignore polemic and not related statements about software which is intended to a completely different user base and served as a nice example when I was a newbee but please do not call me "Dr." because I do not deserve this title.

        [ Reply to this ]
    Re: List of Active FOSS EMR/EHR's
    by Alex Caldwell M.D. on Wednesday June 16, 2004 @ 09:59 PM
    I apologize for my knee-jerk reaction posting. I am sure you are not actually an arrogant person. After all, anyone who has adopted and cared for X-Teddy all this time can't be all bad!

    Tkfp needs to be seen for what it is - we are doctors who see patients every day. We are not engineers or trained programmers. Our area of knowlege is is more in what the doctor's work-flow is like in our corner of the world, and what things would be helpful in daily office practice rather than coding efficiency. We are medical doctors who just taught ourselves enough Linux and scripting level programming to try to tap into the power of Linux and it's associated open source utilities and bring them into our daily practices. Tkfp evolved in that setting. It is not surprising some of our solutions might not be the most efficient possible. But given time, we have come up with some things that we find are very helpful to us. We are using it for all our patient records and billing and getting paid by the 3rd party payors in California and Iowa. I consider this a reasonably succesful accomplishment for an open source project, regardless of the spaghetti code.

    Tkfp is full of legacy and baggage code that represents this timeline of our struggles. There are things that work, things that didn't work. Our later code is somewhat better than the early stuff. But in cases where the early stuff still works, in many cases we haven't gotten around to removing it yet - I like to think of it as kind of like the human genome which also carries a lot non-functional baggage and has new things built on top of old things - at least that gives us an excuse for our coding style!





    [ Reply to this ]
    • Re: List of Active FOSS EMR/EHR's
      by Andreas Tille on Thursday June 17, 2004 @ 06:24 AM
      Alex, I completely understand your situation. I as a physicist have absolutely the same thinking: Just get it working. But over the time I have learned a little bit and found out that a good technical design is evident for any greater project if it should be adopted by others.

      My Debian-Med work is 50% to bring people together and care for good quality software which has the chance to evolve. I'd suggest to discuss this via a better channel than LinuxMedNews (private Mail or OpenHealth list might be apropriate).

      Kind regards

      Andreas.
      [ Reply to this ]
    Re: List of Active FOSS EMR/EHR's
    by Volker E. Bradley, M.D. on Sunday June 20, 2004 @ 09:36 AM
    Thought I'd give you and Dan some updated information regarding FreeMED features:

    1. HL7 Import facility - supports lab
    2. Seamless fax import and export facility
    3. Scanned document mangement system
    4. Messaging center for intraoffice communication
    5. Episode of care - outcomes tracking
    6. Secure access using SSL
    7. Templateable progress notes and letters
    8. Billing and statement facilities
    9. Printing subsystem (browser based, CUPS, LPR)
    10.Call-in patient tracking
    11.System-wide notifications
    12.Prescription lookup and generation engine
    13.Full ledger and claim manager for billing and outstanding clam tracking
    14.VPN capability
    15.LaTeX renderer for high quality printed documents
    16.Fully configurable EMR views per user
    17.Support for multiple languages

    FreeMED is being used by many practices and is actively supported.

    Volker

    [ Reply to this ]
    Re: List of Active FOSS EMR/EHR's
    by willl ross on Monday June 21, 2004 @ 06:38 PM
    Regarding <a href="http://www.primarycarecoalition.org/index.php?content_id=48">CHLCare</a>: they are a small operation with part-time IT staff. Over the past 18 months they built and deployed an EHR currently in production use as an ASP model by about 30,000 patients across several social safety net clinics in Maryland. Their software suite is PHP/Apache/MySQL. They plan to release it under the GPL sometime this year. I've been working with them on adding functionality to the software, and they've been working with me on getting the MPI/EHR project I'm working on to interoperate with theiir CHLCare project. -- [wr]
    [ Reply to this ]
    Re: List of Active FOSS EMR/EHR's
    by Fred Trotter on Wednesday November 30, 2005 @ 07:02 AM
    MirrorMed is a modern Open Source EHR and should be included in the list!!

    -FT
    [ Reply to this ]
    The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them.
    ( Reply )


     
    Google
     
    www.linuxmednews.com Web
    Advertisement: CCHIT certified EMR and Medical Practice Management Software from Medical Software Associates makes patient management easy. Free practice management and medical billing software demo available.
    All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest ©2000-2006 Ignacio Valdes, MD, MS.